Now Driving Online Now Hiring Online Home Seller Subscribe to the JG-TC
10°F
Severe
Who should Democrats choose as their lieutenant governor candidate?
More
Thomas Castillo
Mike Boland
Terry Link
Other
View Results
 






 
Friday, February 13, 2009 8:50 PM CST
COLUMN: Oh how I miss the public at meetings these days



I have found small town public meetings and forums can produce blissful unions with American democracy.

Where else can you show up in street clothes, lean back in a chair and ask questions about something that might dig into your wallet without the threat of being tear gassed or beaten bloody with truncheons? Of course, you might get thrown out if you throw a chair or question the ancestry of an elected official’s mother.

Minding your manners is a bedrock of local government in most communities.

Unfortunately, some people are blind to this fine form of political freedom.

Last summer, there was a pair of public hearings at Mattoon City Hall on a major commercial development question. It concerned many millions of dollars and setting the commercial development agenda on the east side of the town for years to come.

I was the only person not tied to city government or a city employee attending those hearings. There was almost an echo in the city council chambers when the moderator asked for any questions from the audience. I naturally threw out some pertinent questions. The order for adjournment was pronounced and I headed to the newsroom to write my stories after both hearings.

But as I was writing I wondered why two public hearings produced zilch on public input.

History came close to repeating itself this week.

Mattoon Library Board hosted a special meeting Monday to field questions on the upcoming district referendum and only three taxpayers showed up to ask questions or offer their opinions.

I did commend the three gentlemen for coming that night. They deserved praise because each of them asked tough questions and offered honest opinions on the referendum.

The library board is not discouraged by that small turnout. They plan on holding other forums. In addition, they hope to make public presentations to several community organizations before the April 7 vote.

My job will be reporting on future forums and some library board meetings. And my co-worker Rob Stroud and I plan on additional stories on the library district referenda for Charleston and Mattoon in coming weeks. We produced more than 100 inches on the subject last week in the newspaper. I thought there was the possibility that people were fired up over the issue.

The low turnout might indicate no one cares about local government issues anymore. Or maybe they are overjoyed with local government. How could Mattoon residents possibly have any questions on a tax referendum?

By the way, that last question is an attempt at humorous sarcasm.

A more plausible reason might be that people feel unwelcomed at local government hearings or forums. They might think why waste time jabbering when the decision makers are doodling on their agenda sheets? And these angst-driven voters might have already decided to be against something to spite the so-called money grabbers.

Well, I will point out over the last five years there have been times when people have spoken up and made a difference in this town. It happened during the YMCA controversy. Criticism during a council meeting canceled out a hefty land deal a few years ago. For better or worse, these and other past actions by concerned taxpayers helped direct local government. People made a difference.

This recent disengagement of the public is getting eerie in Mattoon. Fortunately, I have learned people don’t like to sit on their hands on major issues in this city.

I cannot really put a fire underneath people. I will continue to cover the governmental meetings and work on getting the facts together as best I can. I’m a reporter not a political agitator.

But I offer this old saying on the potential consequences of indifference, especially in public affairs: Speak up now or forever hold your peace.


Share:          Submit to Reddit         Add to My Yahoo!Add to My Yahoo!   



  Add your comments

*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
  Forgot Your Password?
 

Not already registered?
Then click Here.


JG-TC.com encourages readers to engage in civil conversation with their neighbors. Comments that are submitted are not posted to the site immediately. They go into a queue to be moderated and may take several hours to be reviewed. Comments posted on Saturday may not be reviewed until Sunday afternoon.

In order to keep the page a set width, long lines (mostly long links) will be chopped. Try putting spaces in your links or consider using tinyurl.com to make a smaller link that you can include.

We will never edit or alter your comments, but we do reserve the right to remove comments that violate our code of conduct.

No comment may contain:

* Potentially libelous statements; such as accusing somebody of a crime, defamation of character, or statements that can harm somebody's reputation.
* Obscene, explicit, or racist language.
* Personal attacks, insults, threats, harassment or inciting violence.
* Commercial product promotions.

If you have any questions, please contact our moderator.


Midwest girl wrote on Feb 14, 2009 7:33 AM:

" It's not that people don't care what is going on in Mattoon. Some of us know it doesn't matter what we think or what we know given the current city powers that be. The winds of change will blow soon! Thank God for a free country with elections to boot out officials that do nothing for the people of this city! Except increase their water/sewer rates, raise taxes, cover streets in slag and spend more money fixing their mistakes (including the ones most don't know about!) When is the next election? I can't wait!!!! "

Mike P wrote on Feb 14, 2009 7:36 AM:

" Some of it is likely the 24 hr notice if that, for meeting agendas.

I am not sure if there was a fire, and someone were sitting on their hands, in a bench above it, would this reporter even notice either if it happened in a bully pulpit session. Finding facts beyond whats on the provided hand out, isn't being an agitator, verifying facts on the said provided information, shouldn't have you flashing back to wedgies and under garments being ran up flag poles.

As a reporter, you should question nearly everything, especially the bigger the likely impact on the taxpayer. Start listing the next weeks agenda by Fri edition, if not on the tail end of each weeks mettings coverage. Except for emergency agenda items, there should be more of a heads up for the next weeks items. Give folks a few days to get a sitter, make arrangements, or decide if they can go. Your shift to hey tomorrow at some time, they will discuss and vote on this, probably has directly contributed to turn outs being what they are. Besides, more folks have to work outside of the Mon- Fri 8am to 4pm flexible come and go as you please schedule.

Actually you should be quite familure with folks sitting on their hands. The depot project bidding, was some serious hand sitting, that should have been questioned. FutureGen is a handsitting project. Its evidently structured like a federal funding research grant proposal, to the tune of 2 billion dollars. I think that might be a bit out of the ordinary, and is begining to sound like one of them OMEGA too good to be true, kind of schemes. How is something this backed, and before the economy hit the tank, they are 1.8B before over runs short on getting it off the ground. Same with a convention center on its third draft of attempting to launch an I57 E tif district, in 7 or 8 years, to turn a corn field into a convention center, but this project is evidently viable only as long as it doesn't have to pay all of its taxes, to this city that just had to annex it to be able to throw taxpayers money in and at it.

Speak now or forever hold you peace, isn't quite accurate. If a lot of this stuff isn't done effectively, or by the letter of the law, Citizens can choose several options to confront it directly at a later point.

Your, I am often the only one carrying the water on the taxpayers behalf in these meetings, has so many holes in it, by the time you got to a fire under someone, if you actually noticed it, your water bucket would be carrying only a few drops. You would actually have to be openly questioning things, and bringing vague standard prepared explanations to being expanded, before you get more than just credited for filling one chair in a full or empty peanut gallery at a meeting.

Get your water bucket holes plugged, or invest in a new ergonomic bucket. Start being an open taxpayer advocate, and not a disinterested bystander to these events. If you notice the headcounts, try to notice how the decisions will directly impact the people you miss being there being engaged in the process. Ideally every decision at these meetings, would be based on whats best for the majority of taxpayers. We all know many have been made to benefit few and affect many, and they were done with you sitting back quietly doodling on your note book, or at least with you there representing the paper. If youaren't part of the solutions at all of the groups you cover and attend their meetings, you are part of the problem. Complacency needs to end, and a little devils advocate on everythng needs to be the norm. Stop taking their provided handouts as fact, verify and question things, and it might mean stepping on some of the bullies toes to do it. Some of your past and present coverage of the same things, doesn't even add up. If you want to do this and see it actually mean more than just being a fixture at these meetings, its up to you, to make it more. You've squandered opportunity for years, will continuation be more of the same, or will you begin to take this a bit more seriously, and take some ownership of this happening on your watch. "

vakyin wrote on Feb 14, 2009 8:31 AM:

" They don't attend because they'd rather write disrespectful comments on a stupid message board. "

Rohn Gordon wrote on Feb 14, 2009 10:56 AM:

" Hey Herby that is what several of us has been saying in these blogs also. But anyway great letter. It will reach way more than these blogs do.
What happens though when people do show up and voice their opinions is like what happened to Brad Metcalf. He stood to voice his opinion and Elmer"fud" Smith came across the room and started a argument with him. You guys wrote about it exept you had left out the part where Smith had started it. So everyone that read the article thought that Metcalf had started it because it was about Smith that was the topic to start with. So now when Metcalf posts in here everyone thinks he is a trouble maker, so no matter what he writes will be dismissed as so. When you guys write letters you SHOULD ALWAYS state all of the facts. If you would have added 5 more words then "Smith came across the room" everyone would have KNOWN that Metcalf did NOT start the troubles that the police separate. You people are supposed to tell the story, not just the parts that make the city officials look right. It is us normal folk that keeps you in a job. We buy and read more of your papers that the city does.
Its time for you to become a reporter not a dictation service. I am sure you guys read some of these blogs. You should be tired of the constant ridicule of this papers reporting.
"Report
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

In writing, a report is a document characterized by information or other content reflective of inquiry or investigation, {which is tailored to the context of a given situation and audience.} The purpose of reports is usually to inform."
Tailored to a audience "US" not whats being reported "THEM". "

Equalizer wrote on Feb 14, 2009 1:10 PM:

" I don't know how these things work in Mattoon. In Charleston, however...being told we are not addressing that issue right now, sit down and wait your turn is bad enough. Then when time is running out and you bring up a question again, you are told to sit down and shut up. If brought up again before closing of the meeting, you are then reprimanded and told we already addressed that. Who would want to be keep being treated so badly by primitive savage beasts?
(This was before Mayor John Inyart, don't know if it's still that way.) "

jd50 wrote on Feb 14, 2009 2:10 PM:

" Very nicely put Mr. Meeker! I have experianced the same lack of no shows at our public meetings lately.I"m a member of the Coles County Meth Awareness Coalition,and have personally invited public officials,school board members,general public,firedept personell,clergy and have very little if no response to the efforts put forth.So I feel your frustrations. There still is a serious problem in our community and its not just gonna go away.Ive found that unless somebody is directly effected my something around here they have very little interest until they either experience a death,fire,or find out their responsible for the toxic waste left behind in their rental property,or buy a house that once was used to manufacture meth in and they become violently ill.Then there may be a concern.Anyway I will also continue to go to the town meetings with hopes that I may some day be able to make a positive difference in our community ,hopefully sooner than later.Id like to sincerly thank you,and the JG staff for all the great coverage ya"ll have given the Coalitions efforts.THANKS!! "

shumphreys wrote on Feb 15, 2009 8:35 AM:

" I don't know what the public comments policy is for Mattoon and I suspect many others (including residents) don't know either. If you want to present an issue in Oakland a person can contact the clerk and ask to be put on the agenda. If someone shows up at the meeting unannounced (or if the clerk forgot) the mayor chats with them to find out what they are there for and her first item of business is to put them on the agenda. Then there is usually a public comments space on the agenda. For special meetings where advanced notice is given well ahead of time very few other than council members show up. People forget that our form of government is called participatory, and that means that you have to get involved. "

Becky wrote on Feb 16, 2009 7:54 AM:

" Maybe we are all working our behinds off there Mr. Meeker! Maybe most of us have to work several jobs in order to pay our CIPS bill, water bill, property taxes, doctor bills, food. You know all those luxuries that we like in our lives. When and if we get some time to stop working....WE SLEEP! "

English Bob wrote on Feb 16, 2009 9:33 AM:

" ((BECKY WROTE)) "Maybe we are all working our behinds off there Mr. Meeker! Maybe most of us have to work several jobs in order to pay our CIPS bill, water bill, property taxes, doctor bills, food. You know all those luxuries that we like in our lives. When and if we get some time to stop working....WE SLEEP! " ((TO WHICH I ADD, OR WE READ JG-TC.COM AND POST COMMENTS, A LOT. CHEERS.)) "

jd50 wrote on Feb 16, 2009 10:25 AM:

" BECKY; Im sorry you feel that way! "

Rockin Rotty wrote on Feb 16, 2009 10:52 AM:

" What Becky said. "

shumphreys wrote on Feb 16, 2009 3:57 PM:

" Becky your point is well made AND it is also part of the problem, why participatory democracy has often been relegated to the social elites, those that can afford to participate. AND that creates problems, like no one looking out for YOUR interests. If the current financial mess doesn't make the point clear, I don't know what will. "

Lurker61920 wrote on Feb 16, 2009 4:21 PM:

" Shumphreys, will free birth contol help the current financial mess? "

shumphreys wrote on Feb 16, 2009 4:59 PM:

" Lurker I haven't suggested FREE birth control as a way out of the financial mess BUT it will help peoples budgets, it will help stop unwanted prenancies, and it will help prevent the spread of STD's, and it will keep the population down and keep parents from having more children than they can afford....so yes it will help us out of the financial mess. "

yeah right wrote on Feb 16, 2009 10:31 PM:

" If you post more then three paragraphs, you have to much time on your hands.... Mike P.....lol

sorry, no offense. "

CHILL! wrote on Feb 18, 2009 6:24 PM:

" yeah right wrote on Feb 16, 2009 10:31 PM:
" If you post more then three paragraphs, you have to much time on your hands.... Mike P.....lol

sorry, no offense. "

LOL I say the same, yeah right! "

attainedage wrote on Feb 20, 2009 10:50 PM:

" yeah right, I doubt that Mike P takes your "no offense" comment seriously. Your comments are reasonably brief and I agree that Mike is almost always too wordy. Could that be a reliable indicator that Mile's attention span is much longer than yours? LOL "

jd50 wrote on Feb 21, 2009 9:21 AM:

" shumprie,Whats that got to do with the price a rice in china? "

HisChild wrote on Feb 22, 2009 2:22 PM:

" Fascinating that this letter is still here, but the Recycling one is in the archives.
And it still has people posting. "

 


COLUMN: Oh how I miss the public at meetings these days

COLUMN: My new Craftsman inflator may blow the lid off my sanity

OUR VIEW: Hi-Cone's 40-year plan simple, effective

OUR VIEW: Soldiers a 'costly sacrifice upon the altar of Freedom'

LETTER: Chicago Democrat to turn country around?

LETTER: Pork projects plentiful in federal stimulus bill

LETTER: Facts suggest Lincoln conclusions incorrect

LETTER: Quinn will be governor of the entire state

LETTER: Alternatives exist to having abortions

LETTER: Recycling concerns still don't have answers

LETTER: Sign needed to direct trucks around the city

LETTER: Disaster relief tax break offered for education

LETTER: Abortion foes want to protect unborn life

LETTER: 'Domestic tranquility' requires compromise

LETTER: Obama appoints his own 'good ole boys'

LETTER: People have a right to protect their property

LETTER: Donnelley plant has impact on I-57 traffic

LETTER: Lincoln fails test on civil liberties

OUR VIEW: Survey says: Help teens make good choices

LETTER: Save innocent babies, rather than whales

LETTER: Act's intent is to put Roe v. Wade into law


 




©2007 Journal Gazette and Times-Courier, divisions of Lee Enterprises.    JG/T-C Do Not Call Policy    Privacy Policy    Contact Us
Tab
Content